Yania v. Bigan
397 Pa. 316 · Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1959
Facts
John Bigan operated a strip mine with a deep, water-filled cut. Joseph Yania, a business visitor, jumped from a high embankment into the water and drowned after Bigan allegedly urged, enticed, and taunted him. Yania's widow sued Bigan for negligence, claiming Bigan failed to warn of the danger and failed to rescue Yania.
Issue
Did Bigan owe a legal duty to Yania, an adult in full possession of his faculties, such that Bigan could be held liable for Yania's death by drowning, either for allegedly taunting him to jump, failing to warn of an obvious danger, or failing to rescue him?
Holding
The court affirmed the lower court's decision, finding that Bigan owed no legal duty to Yania under the circumstances, and thus was not liable for his death. The facts pleaded did not establish a cause of action for negligence.
Rule
An adult in full possession of their faculties is not deprived of volition by mere taunting or enticement, and a landowner has no duty to warn a business invitee of an obvious danger. Furthermore, there is no legal duty to rescue a person in peril unless the defendant was legally responsible for placing them in that dangerous situation.
Read the full opinion on CourtListener
Case brief last reviewed . Prepared by CaseReader from the published opinion.